---

How to Use the Debt vs Investment Calculator

---

1. Enter Debt Details:
   • In the Debts section, provide details for each of your debts. Enter the debt type, the outstanding amount, the interest rate, and the monthly payment.
   • Use the Add Another Debt button if you have multiple debts, or remove rows if necessary.
2. Enter Investment Details:
   • In the Investments section, enter your investment information.
   • Input the investment type, your initial investment amount, your planned monthly contribution, and the expected return rate.
   • Add or remove investment rows using the corresponding buttons.
3. Enter Global Settings:
   • Scroll down to fill in the global parameters:
     • Capital Gains Tax Rate (%): The tax rate applied to the gains from your investments.
     • Inflation Rate (%): The expected annual inflation rate. This is used to adjust the future value of your investments into today’s dollars.
     • Investment Duration (Years): The number of years you plan to invest or work on paying down your debt.
4. Calculate:
   • Click the Calculate button to process your inputs.
   • The calculator will compute the future value of your investments, the total cost of your debts (interest and remaining balance), and generate a recommendation.
5. Review Results:
   • The results section will display:
     • Investments: Projected future values (before and after tax), total contributions, tax on gains, and inflation-adjusted value.
     • Debts: Total interest paid over the period and the remaining debt balance.
     • Recommendation: Guidance on whether to invest or pay down debt based on the calculated net gains versus debt interest.

---

---

Output Explanations

Most people have a combination of debt and the potential for investments.

The question is, do you pay down your debt or invest?

We are hoping that with our debt vs investment calculator, we can help you make a decision founded in logic and fact.

The Financial Crossroads: Investing vs. Debt Payment 🌟

Making smart money decisions isn’t just about mathematical formulas – it’s about understanding your unique financial journey and creating deliberate pathways to wealth that match your life circumstances.

Should I Invest or Pay Off Debt First? 📊

This common question deserves a nuanced approach that considers both the numbers and your personal situation:

The Mathematical Perspective:

• When investment returns (after taxes) exceed your debt interest rate, investing theoretically creates more wealth
• When debt interest rates exceed realistic investment returns, debt payment provides a guaranteed “return”
• Example: A 17% credit card versus a potential 9% market return isn’t just an 8% difference – it’s the difference between guaranteed savings and potential earnings

The Reality Factors:

• Risk tolerance plays a crucial role – market investments can fluctuate significantly
• Psychological weight of debt creates cognitive burdens that affect decision-making
• Cash flow considerations might make one path more practical than another

---

Related Calculators

• ISA Calculator: Estimate the potential growth of your Individual Savings Account investments.

• AER Calculator: Calculate the Annual Equivalent Rate to understand the real return on your savings or investments.

• BMR Calculator: Determine your Basal Metabolic Rate to plan your dietary and fitness goals.

• BMI Calculator: Find out your Body Mass Index to assess your health status.

• Percentage Calculator: Perform various percentage calculations with ease.

---

The Practical Framework:

1. Always capture employer matching (typically 50-100% guaranteed returns)
2. Eliminate high-interest debt (above 8-10%) before investing beyond matched contributions
3. Build emergency savings before accelerating moderate-interest debt payments
4. Consider a balanced approach with moderate-interest debt (4-8%)

Is It Better to Invest or Pay Down Mortgage? 🏠

Mortgage decisions deserve special consideration due to their long-term nature:

The Unique Mortgage Factors:

• Mortgage interest is typically lower (3-6%) than potential long-term market returns (7-10% historical average)
• Mortgage interest may be tax-deductible, effectively lowering the true interest rate
• Home equity isn’t liquid without borrowing against it
• Psychological value of owning your home outright

Strategic Considerations:

• Investment timeframe matters enormously – longer investment horizons better absorb market volatility
• Inflation typically devalues fixed-rate mortgage debt over time while potentially helping investment growth
• Early mortgage years primarily pay interest, making additional principal payments more impactful

Real-World Example:

A homeowner with a 4% mortgage might generate 7% average returns in a diversified portfolio over 15+ years, creating significantly more wealth than early mortgage payoff. However, this comes with market risk that the guaranteed 4% savings doesn’t have.

How to Decide Between Investing and Debt Payoff ⚖️

Decision-making frameworks work best when they integrate multiple dimensions:

The Interest Rate Hierarchy:

• Emergency fund (1-2 months expenses) comes first regardless of other factors
• Employer retirement matches second (typically 50-100% returns)
• High-interest debt (>8%) third, as it outpaces realistic market returns
• Balanced approach for moderate-interest debt (4-8%)
• Long-term investing with low-interest debt (<4%)

The Personal Factor Assessment:

• Sleep factor – debt that keeps you awake deserves priority regardless of interest rate
• Income stability – less stable income favors debt reduction for improved future flexibility
• Life stage – proximity to major transitions (retirement, education needs) influences priorities
• Risk capacity – your ability to weather financial setbacks affects optimal strategy

Decision Integration Process:

1. Assess all relevant factors (interest rates, tax implications, risk tolerance)
2. Apply weighted importance based on personal circumstances
3. Create a sequential path with clear transition triggers
4. Schedule regular reassessment points as conditions change

When to Prioritize Investments Over Student Loans 🎓

Student loans present unique considerations in the debt-vs-investment decision:

Student Loan Specifics:

• Federal loans often offer income-driven repayment options
• Potential loan forgiveness programs create strategic opportunities
• Interest rates vary dramatically (2-10%) based on loan type and timing
• Tax deductibility of student loan interest (subject to income limits)

Investment Priority Triggers:

• When student loan interest rates are below 5% (especially with tax deductibility)
• When retirement time horizon exceeds 15+ years
• When employee matching contributions are available
• When you qualify for income-driven repayment with potential forgiveness

Balanced Approach Example:
A professional with $40,000 in federal student loans at 4.5% interest might prioritize capturing their employer’s 5% 401(k) match (effectively a 100% return), then build a 3-month emergency fund, and finally split additional savings between moderate student loan prepayment and long-term investments based on risk tolerance.

The Integration Mindset 🧠

Remember that personal finance rarely presents true either/or scenarios – the most successful wealth-builders often implement graduated approaches:

• Capture guaranteed returns (employer matches) first
• Eliminate sleep-disrupting debt regardless of interest rate
• Build sufficient emergency reserves before aggressive investment
• Consider partial approaches (50% to debt, 50% to investments)
• Reassess as interest rates, tax laws, and personal circumstances evolve

The wealthiest individuals don’t just understand the numbers – they understand how financial decisions integrate into their broader life goals and personal psychology.